Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile


You didn't ask for second opinion, but here it is.

October 02, 2020 12:22PM

I'm not looking to start an argument, but i think varying perspectives are valuable.

I have well over 200 hrs on my MX Sport w/ the 7" Detec DD. Over 20 hour w/ the 6" concentric. Likely many more hours than i suggested on both. I'm typically running the Coin/Jewelry program with a 7 gain, accepting targets to -10 or -20, and iron audio silent. Why the big disparity in coil time?

Well, i tested them both on in ground target - coins and gold as well as the nail board. The 7" DD outperforms on the nail board - more solid hits - 7 ish. It hits targets with meaningfully more depth. It has slightly more coverage. It's VDI's may not be perfect at depth, but i found them to often be more accurate on the nail board, compared to the concentric, considering the iron impacts. That ounce of gold i found last year....most of it with the 7" DD. I tried the concentric, but just was not getting the same inground result on small gold. One can argue it was because i didn't put 200 hours on the concentric, or i didn't get the coil over the target. I have a different opinion.

I did see that Monte referenced the silver stack test. Haven't done that... and am not likely to. Why, because its very unlikely I'll happen upon that exact spill scenario compared to the hundreds of other scenarios i will encounter. Will i miss one.....it's possible. But i do know what i may be missing if I'm using the 6" concentric in favor or the 7" DD.

So, I think the 7" DD is a fine coil for everything i do. I did run the concentric the other day because i didn't want to catch up on stubble and brush. I posted a pretty good selection of finds, including a half dollar. Sure, it works...and it had a purpose on that day.

BTW - i think the 4x6DD is also FANTASTIC. Outperforms the 5.3 concentric on my V3i setups which are very, very similar for both. Have done a lot of nail board testing w/ both. 8-8 with the 4x6. I have several hundred hours on both of them....but if you make me pick one in a ghost town, i'm using the 4x6 because my testing and infield experience say I get better results. The 5.3 goes bit deeper in terms of coverage at depth, but in the ghost town, i don't care. 4" is enough for both in most circumstances.

I'm at the point where i've done enough testing. No real interest in going back and checking nuances and slight alterations. If someone were to show where i have a setting adjustment that could flip/flop the results in a meaningful way, i'd certainly listen....but i don't expect it after many, many tests over the last 7 years.

My point is, i think much of this comes down to what you measure/test against, and personal preferences. I couldn't care less which one i swing...so long as I'm maximizing my opportunity...and that is what i do.

Just one mans opinion. Best to you.

Happy Hunting.

Subject Author Views Posted

Its not fair Attachments

OregonGregg 128 September 29, 2020 09:33AM

Taking Action -

UtahRich 64 October 01, 2020 12:31PM

Re: Taking Action -

OregonGregg 50 October 05, 2020 05:34AM

Looking for Magnum PI Ferrari 308 GTS in pristine condition - low miles

UtahRich 36 October 05, 2020 04:00PM

Re: Taking Action -

Druid 54 October 02, 2020 05:01PM

Re: Taking Action -

SvenS 35 October 04, 2020 05:13AM

From Canada, land of the Maple Leaf and . . . Books.

UtahRich 48 October 02, 2020 08:52PM

Re: Taking Action -

diggindeep 47 October 01, 2020 01:19PM

Field Trips -

UtahRich 38 October 01, 2020 03:35PM

Thanks everyone for the comments. Attachments

OregonGregg 41 September 30, 2020 09:54PM

Re: Thanks everyone for the comments.

Druid 31 October 02, 2020 05:04PM

Re: Thanks everyone for the comments.

WM6 32 October 03, 2020 01:14AM

Re: Its not fair

Dan'o 40 September 29, 2020 07:37PM

Re: Its not fair

desertsmith 43 September 29, 2020 04:12PM

Re: Its not fair thumbs up

EL NINO 39 September 29, 2020 03:52PM

Re: Its not fair

jmaryt 52 September 29, 2020 02:32PM

Well, I guess 2 good coils out-of 3 isn't too bad.

Monte 45 September 29, 2020 12:06PM

Re: Its not fair

Timbertodd 43 September 29, 2020 11:10AM

Re: Its not fair

D&P-OR 47 September 29, 2020 10:17AM

Now its on!

zincoln 60 September 29, 2020 10:11AM

Re: Now its on! Attachments

Kickindirt 49 October 01, 2020 02:31PM

Re: Now its on!

Druid 32 October 02, 2020 05:06PM

Re: Now its on!

OregonGregg 32 October 02, 2020 05:58AM

Re: Now its on!

Kickindirt 31 October 02, 2020 11:27AM

Joel, OregonGregg said I'd comment on the Detech 7" DD .... so I will. Attachments

Monte 46 October 01, 2020 06:23PM

Re: Joel, OregonGregg said I'd comment on the Detech 7" DD .... so I will.

Kickindirt 36 October 02, 2020 11:19AM

You didn't ask for second opinion, but here it is.

zincoln 39 October 02, 2020 12:22PM

A good reply, Brian, which brought a few things to mind.

Monte 32 October 03, 2020 08:04AM

Your coil was probably fine...

zincoln 33 October 03, 2020 08:54PM

Re: Your coil was probably fine... Attachments

EL NINO 35 October 05, 2020 07:16AM

Nope.sad smiley That particular 7" DD wasn't.thumbs down

Monte 32 October 04, 2020 09:42AM

Re: You didn't ask for second opinion, but here it is. Thanks

Kickindirt 35 October 02, 2020 04:38PM

Sometime get w/'Zincoln' and try both, or get with me and try the 6½" Concentric.

Monte 41 October 02, 2020 12:03PM

Have my eyes deceived me?

UtahRich 35 October 02, 2020 09:01PM

No, your eyes didn't deceive you. And i did say "and maybe..."

Monte 31 October 03, 2020 08:33AM

Re: Now its on!

OregonGregg 30 October 01, 2020 04:37PM

oh !! its on.

OregonGregg 42 September 29, 2020 02:46PM

Is this the line for tickets to the Matinee? I hear it's a Western Gunbattle.smiling bouncing smiley N/T

UtahRich 33 September 29, 2020 09:40PM

Get your tickets......... Attachments

OregonGregg 49 September 30, 2020 11:49AM

Re: Get your tickets.........

DW-BGW 41 September 30, 2020 02:33PM

Re: Get your tickets.........

NWCindy 29 October 05, 2020 04:58PM

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login

Online Users

Guests: 41
Record Number of Users: 13 on January 18, 2018
Record Number of Guests: 356 on August 30, 2020